Our Menu

Our Menu Selections

Our Menu Selections


Stuffed Pizza* – The One That Made Us Famous!

Filled with 100% mozzarella cheese and your choice of fresh ingredients, topped with our signature sweet pizza sauce.

Please place orders 1 hour before closing. We take the time to fully cook our pizzas in a bakers oven.

Please allow 45 min. to 1 hr. for pick-up and 1 hr. 15 min. for delivery.

Seasoned Chicago Style Pizza — Highland, IN — Arrenello's Pizza
Small – 10″ Medium – 12″ Large – 14″
100% Mozzarella Cheese
Fresh Sausage
Each Extra Ingredient

Thin Crust Pizza

Our crispy thin crust is topped with 100% mozzarella cheese and your choice of fresh ingredients.

Small – 10″ Medium – 13″ Large – 15″ Family – 18″
100% Mozzarella Cheese
Fresh Sausage
Each Extra Ingredient

Gluten Free Pizza Crust Available on 10″ Size Only – Add $2.00. Gluten-free crust pizza are prepared in a sterile environment, but are finished in our kitchen where wheat and wheat products are present. 

Extra Thick Crust Pizza

Our extra thick crust is topped with 100% mozzarella cheese and your choice of fresh ingredients.

Small – 10″ Medium – 13″ Large – 15″ Family – 18″
100% Mozzarella Cheese
Fresh Sausage
Each Extra Ingredient

Thats-a-some-fresh-ingredients!

Anchovies

Chicken Strips*

Italian Beef*

Roasted Red Peppers*

Artichokes*

BBQ Chicken*

Jalapeños

Beef Sausage*

Real Bacon Bits*

Chicken Sausage*

Meatballs*

Fresh Sausage

Real Bacon Strips*

Giardinera*

Mushrooms

Fresh Shrimp*

Canadian Bacon

Fresh Garlic

Fresh Onions

Fresh Spinach

Fresh Broccoli

Green Peppers

Pepperoni

Fresh Tomatoes

Black Olives

Green Olives

Pineapple*

Anchovies

Chicken Strips*

Italian Beef*

Roasted Red Peppers*

Artichokes*

BBQ Chicken*

Jalapeños

Beef Sausage*

Real Bacon Bits*

Chicken Sausage*

Meatballs*

Fresh Sausage

Real Bacon Strips*

Giardinera*

Mushrooms

Fresh Shrimp*

Canadian Bacon

Fresh Garlic

Fresh Onions

Fresh Spinach

Fresh Broccoli

Green Peppers

Pepperoni

Fresh Tomatoes

Black Olives

Green Olives

Pineapple*

*Double Charge


All 1/4, 1/2 and 3/4 ingredient portions will be charged as a full ingredient.

Thats-a-some-fresh-ingredients!

Anchovies

Chicken Strips*

Italian Beef*

Roasted Red Peppers*

Artichokes*

BBQ Chicken*

Jalapeños

Real Bacon Bits*

Chicken Sausage*

Fresh Sausage

Real Bacon Strips*

Giardinera*

Mushrooms

Fresh Shrimp*

Canadian Bacon

Fresh Garlic

Fresh Onions

Fresh Spinach

Fresh Broccoli

Green Peppers

Pepperoni

Fresh Tomatoes

Black Olives

Green Olives

Pineapple*

*Double Charge


All 1/4, 1/2 and 3/4 ingredient portions will be charged as a full ingredient.

Chicken Wings

Arrenello’s wings will get your taste buds soaring! Hot, BBQ or plain wings, breaded, naked or boneless. BBQ Sauce: Hot, Sweet Baby Ray’s or Open Pit.

5 Chicken Wings
10 Chicken Wings
20 Chicken Wings
50 Chicken Wings

Blue Cheese or Ranch Dip – add $1.00

Chicken By The Box – Broasted, Hot or BBQ

Your taste buds will dance when you try our tender chicken broasted or smothered in sauce.

(Sweet Baby Ray’s or Open Pit)

Broasted BBQ / Hot
2 pc. Box Chicken
4 pc. Box Chicken
8 pc. Box Chicken
12 pc. Box Chicken
16 pc. Box Chicken
20 pc. Box Chicken

All White Meat (Breast/Wing) on Any Chicken Order – Add $0.90 for 2 pcs., Add $1.75 for 4 pcs.

Chicken By The Box – Broasted, Hot or BBQ

Your taste buds will dance when you try our tender chicken broasted or smothered in sauce.

(Sweet Baby Ray’s or Open Pit)

Broasted BBQ / Hot
2 pc. Box Chicken
4 pc. Box Chicken
8 pc. Box Chicken
12 pc. Box Chicken
16 pc. Box Chicken
20 pc. Box Chicken

All White Meat (Breast/Wing) on Any Chicken Order – Add $0.95 for 2 pcs., Add $1.90 for 4 pcs.

Chicken Dinners – Broasted, BBQ or Hot

Our extra thick crust is topped with 100% mozzarella cheese and your choice of fresh ingredients.

Broasted BBQ / Hot
2 pc. Chicken Dinner | 1 order of french fries, or 2 seasoned or broasted potatoes, small cole slaw & bread.
4 pc. Chicken Dinner | 1 order of french fries, or 3 seasoned or broasted potatoes, small cole slaw & bread.
8 pc. Chicken Dinner | 2 orders of french fries, or 8 seasoned or broasted potatoes, 1/2 lb. cole slaw & bread.
12 pc. Chicken Dinner | 3 orders of french fries, or 12 seasoned or broasted potatoes, 1lb. cole slaw & bread.
16 pc. Chicken Dinner | 4 orders of french fries, or 16 seasoned or broasted potatoes, 1-1/2lb. cole slaw & bread.
20 pc. Chicken Dinner | 5 orders of french fries, or 20 seasoned or broasted potatoes, 2lb. cole slaw & bread.

All White Meat (Breast/Wing) on Any Chicken Order – Add $0.95 for 2pcs., Add $1.90 for 4 pcs.

Sandwiches

Our beef is cooked the old fashioned way. First we roast it slowly in our ovens. Then we trim it and slice it so it can soak up the juices and melt in your mouth

Italian Beef – Topped with spaghetti sauce or natural beef gravy
B.B.Q. Beef – Sliced thin with lotsa sauce
Buffalo Beef – Sliced thin topped with Buffalo sauce
Beef & Cheddar – Sliced thin with melted cheddar
Mom’s Italian Sausage – Fried & covered in spaghetti sauce
Kev’s Beef – Spices, tomatoes & mozzarella cheese
Beef & Sausage Combo – A tantalizing teaming of our beef & sausage
Mom’s Homemade Meatball – Covered with spaghetti sauce
Italian Sub – Ham, salami, pepperoni, red onion, lettuce, tomato, mayo & Italian dressing
Ham Sandwich – Thinly sliced imported ham stacked on our homemade french bread with lettuce, tomatoes and mayo. Served hot or cold.

Our perfectly seasoned chicken breast sandwiches are sure to please.

Chicken Sandwich – Served on a bun with mayo, lettuce & tomato
B.B.Q. Chicken Sandwich
Italian Chicken Sandwich – Topped with our spaghetti sauce & mozzarella cheese
Chicken Caesar Sandwich – Romaine, mozzarella cheese & tomato
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich – Lettuce, tomato, red onion & mayo
BLT Chicken Sandwich – Bacon, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo
Chicken Cordon Bleu – Ranch dressing, mozzarella, Canadian bacon, tomatoes & lettuce
Bacon Ranch Chicken Sandwich – Ranch, lettuce & tomatoes
Served on Garlic Bread – add $0.70
Topped with Mushroom, Bacon, or Roasted Red Peppers – add $1.00 each.
Topped with American, Mozzarella or Cheddar Cheese – add $1.00 each
Add a Cup of Pepperoncini, Jalapenos or Giardinera for $1.50 each.

Salads

All salads are served with bread and your choice of dressing.

Dressing choices: Italian, Garlic, French, Ranch, Honey Mustard, Balsamic Vinaigrette, or Creamy Balsamic. Bleu cheese, Hot Bacon, or Caesar. – add $0.90.

Mediterranean Salad — Highland, IN — Arrenello's Pizza
Small Large
House Salad | A garden fresh mixture of crisp lettuce, tomatoes and cucumbers.
Antipasto Salad | A mixture of Genoa salami, imported ham, pepperoni and mozzarella cheese served on crisp lettuce, topped with tomato, black olive and pepperoncini with choice of dressing.
Garbage Salad | A mixture of crisp lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, bacon bits, hard-boiled eggs, sliced red onions and green olives.
Italian Salad | A mixture of romaine, iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts, mozzarella cheese and black olives.
Spinach Salad | Your choice of hot bacon or Italian dressing over fresh spinach leaves, real bacon bits, sliced hardboiled eggs, tomatoes and garnished with sliced red onions.
Caesar Salad | Fresh romaine lettuce, topped with crunchy croutons, tomatoes and red onions.
Chicken Caesar Salad | Fresh romaine lettuce, topped with crunchy croutons, tomatoes, red onions and chicken strips.
Buffalo Chicken Salad | Lettuce, tomato, cucumber and red onion.
Chicken BLT Salad | Fresh Romaine lettuce topped with bacon, chicken and tomatoes
Top any Salad with Bacon,Chicken or Shrimp
Appetizers
Small Large
Golden French Fries
Onion Rings
Battered Zucchini*
Breaded Mushrooms or Cauliflower*
Spicy Jalapeno Poppers*
100% Mozzarella Sticks*
Wisconsin Cheese Curds*
Breaded Cheese Ravioli*
Broasted Potatoes
Seasoned Broasted Potatoes
Plain Potato Skin
Italian Potato Skin
American Potato Skins
Macaroni & Cheese
Garlic Bread – Fresh baked like Mama’s
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Pizza Bread – Topped with pizza sauce, garlic & mozzarella cheese
Tomato Bread– Topped with garlic, tomatoes & mozzarella cheese
Additional Topping on Pizza or Tomato Bread
Chicken Breast Strips*
Buffalo Chicken Strips
BBQ Breast Strips (Sauce: Open Pit or Sweet Baby Ray’s
Cole Slaw - Sm – 1.50
Rolls
Cup of Cheddar Cheese
Salad Dressing, Tartar, Cocktail or BBQ Sauce
Romano Cheese (1 oz.)
Red Pepper Flakes (2 oz.)
Giardinera or Jalapenos (4 oz. cup)

Pepperoncini (8 oz. cup)

*Cucumber sauce, honey mustard or marinara sauce upon request only, no charge.

Desserts
Turtle Cheesecake
Chocolate Cake
German Chocolate Cake
Carrot Cake
Tiramisu
Vegetable Pasta — Highland, IN — Arrenello's Pizza

Pasta

Arrenello’s pastas are freshly made and topped with our own special sauces. All dishes are served with grated cheese and bread.

Sauce Choices:

Marinara – Our meatless marinara sauce is a delicious blend of vegetables, delicately seasoned and cooked to perfection.

Meat Sauce – Our meat marinara sauce is a superb blend of meat, spices, and the finest California tomatoes, cooked and simmered for hours.

Alfredo Sauce – Tired of red sauce? Try Arrenello’s creamy Alfredo sauce – add $2.50.

Spaghetti
Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce and Shrimp
Baked Spaghetti – Topped with 100% mozzarella cheese
Mostaccioli
Baked Mostaccioli – Topped with 100% mozzarella cheese
Ravioli – Meat or cheese
Baked Ravioli – Filled with meat or cheese and topped with mozzarella
Fettucine – Thin, ribbonlike strips of pasta with red sauce
Fettucine Alfredo – Buttery, creamy parmesan sauce
Fettucine Alfredo with Grilled Chicken
Fettucine Alfredo with Shrimp
Fettucine Alfredo with Mushrooms or Broccoli
Chicken Parmigiana – On a bed of spaghetti | Lasagna
Lasagna
Penne Pomodoro– Olive oil fresh spinach, broccoli, onions, garlic, oregano, and light marinara sauce
Jumbo Stuffed Shells -Homemade shells stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella & parmesan

Add a meatball – $1.70 each

Add a sausage – $2.75 each

Add grilled chicken strips or shrimp – $3.95

Add broccoli or mushrooms – $1.25

Ribs

We select only the finest baby back ribs the market has to offer. Served smothered in Sweet Baby Rays or Open Pit BBQ Sauce.


Dinners include golden french fries, original or seasoned broasted potatoes, cole slaw, a roll, and sauce.

Vegetable Pasta — Highland, IN — Arrenello's Pizza
Ribs Only Dinner
1/2 Slab BBQ Baby Back Ribs
Full Slab BBQ Baby Back Ribs
2 pc. Chicken & 1/2 Slab Ribs Combo

Seafood

Our seafood dinners include golden french fries, original or seasoned broasted potatoes, cole slaw, bread, tartar sauce or cocktail sauce.

Seafood Only Dinner
Small Jumbo Shrimp Original, Buffalo or BBQ (6-8 pcs., Apx. 1/2 lb.)
Medium Jumbo Shrimp Original, Buffalo or BBQ (12-16 pcs., Apx. 1 lb.)
Large Jumbo Shrimp Original, Buffalo or BBQ (18-24 pcs., Apx. 1.5 lbs.)
Small Cod Tavern battered filets (3-4 pcs., Apx. 1/2 lb.)
Medium Cod Tavern battered filets (6-8 pcs., Apx. 1 lb.)
Large Cod Tavern battered filets (9-12 pcs.,Apx. 1.5 lbs)
Small Perch (6-7pcs. Apx. 1/2 lb.)
Medium Perch (12-14 pcs. Apx. 1 lb.)
Large Perch (18-21 pcs. Apx. 1.5 lbs.)
Share by: